Manchester United: why the problem is not just the manager

Updated 13 November 2026: Manchester United announce Mauricio Pochettino as their new head coach. See "What is happening now".

Standfirst: Manchester United look set to change manager again, and the name most often mentioned is Mauricio Pochettino. But the Manchester United crisis began long before this manager. Since 2013 the club has changed coaches, executives and strategy again and again. We look at the evidence to understand what is really going wrong, with respect for supporters who have been waiting a long time.

What is happening now

13 November 2026

  • Closing update: Manchester United have officially announced Mauricio Pochettino as their men's first-team head coach from 18 November. The club has agreed with the U.S. Soccer Federation for him and his staff to be released once their national-team commitments end (official club statement). The Manchester Evening News reports a contract to 2029 and a first game at Liverpool on Sunday 22 November. This closes our updates: United are second from bottom with 8 points from 10 games (La Repubblica), and the underlying question this article raises remains the club's structure, not just who sits in the dugout.

12 November 2026

  • The club has officially confirmed that Michael Carrick has left his role as men’s first-team head coach. In a statement, United said that after a “disappointing start to the season” it had come to the “extremely difficult conclusion that a change is necessary”, and that it intends to appoint a permanent successor “as quickly as possible”. The club said Carrick is, and always will be, “a Manchester United legend” (official statement).
  • United remain 18th in the Premier League after 10 matches, in the relegation zone. It is their lowest position at this stage of a top-flight season since 1986-87 (BBC Sport).
  • There is still no official announcement of the new head coach. BBC Sport reports that a deal with Mauricio Pochettino and his staff is being finalised and that he may take training on 18 or 19 November, after his commitments with the USA national team; the Guardian describes a framework agreement, with details still to be settled. Until the club confirms it, he has not been officially appointed.
  • This announcement confirms it is the third season in a row in which United have backed a manager in the summer, given him money for signings and then sacked him mid-season (BBC Sport).

11 November 2026

  • The current head coach is still Michael Carrick, although his departure is widely expected. United are 18th in the Premier League after 10 matches, in the relegation zone. It is their lowest position at this stage of a top-flight season since 1986-87 (BBC Sport).
  • A meeting is taking place in Monaco today between Sir Jim Ratcliffe (co-owner), Omar Berrada (chief executive) and Jason Wilcox (director of football). According to the BBC and the Guardian, Berrada and Wilcox will recommend that Carrick is dismissed. The Glazer family, the majority shareholders, must also approve.
  • Pochettino: still no official announcement, though the reporting has strengthened. BBC Sport says United have opened talks with him and that he is ready to accept; the Guardian says the club are "closing in" on a deal; Sky Sports reports that an agreement in principle is already in place, with details still to be finalised. Pochettino is the USA head coach and has a release clause of about $10m (£7.5m). At the time of writing, the club has made no official announcement.
  • If confirmed, it would be the third season in a row in which United have backed a manager in the summer, given him money for signings and then sacked him mid-season (BBC Sport).

Thirteen and a half years in numbers

Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013 after winning the league. Since then:

  • Seven permanent managers: David Moyes, Louis van Gaal, José Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Erik ten Hag, Rúben Amorim and Michael Carrick, plus five interim managers. Pochettino would be the eighth.
  • No league titles. Final positions range from 2nd to 15th, with an average of 5.4.
  • Five major trophies: the FA Cup (2016 and 2024), the League Cup (2017 and 2023) and the Europa League (2017).
SeasonMain manager(s)League position
2013-14Moyes (Giggs interim)7th
2014-15Van Gaal4th
2015-16Van Gaal5th
2016-17Mourinho6th
2017-18Mourinho2nd
2018-19Mourinho / Solskjaer6th
2019-20Solskjaer3rd
2020-21Solskjaer2nd
2021-22Solskjaer / Rangnick (interim)6th
2022-23Ten Hag3rd
2023-24Ten Hag8th
2024-25Ten Hag / Amorim15th
2025-26Amorim / Carrick3rd

Table sources: Premier League and BBC Sport.

The core question: managers or structure?

Our working idea is that the problem lies less with each manager and more with how the club is run. We do not take that for granted: we test it against the evidence.

What supports the idea

1. When Ferguson left, the club lost more than a manager. As the BBC explained in 2018, Ferguson handled the team, recruitment and the playing philosophy, so in practice the club also lost its director of football. A director of football (or sporting director) plans the squad for the long term, leads recruitment and chooses the head coach. United did not create that post until March 2021, eight years later.

2. The leadership has changed almost as often as the dugout. Ed Woodward ran the club until February 2022; he was followed by Richard Arnold, who left at the end of 2023. In 2024 Ratcliffe and his company, INEOS, arrived, with Omar Berrada as chief executive, Dan Ashworth as sporting director and Jason Wilcox as technical director. Ashworth lasted five months. According to the BBC, he left after a disagreement over who should replace Ten Hag.

3. There has been money; good decisions, less so. According to a Transfermarkt tally published in the summer of 2026, since 2013-14 United had spent about €2.32bn on signings and had the highest net spend (fees paid minus fees received) of any club in the world over that period, about €1.59bn. Sky Sports calculates that, since 2022, United have the highest net spend in the Premier League (£769.5m), but only 19% of it went on defenders. That imbalance shows today: the team has conceded 30 goals in 15 matches this season, in all competitions (BBC Sport).

4. An ownership model that has cost the club a great deal. The Glazers bought United in 2005 with borrowed money and placed that debt on the club itself. BBC Verify calculates that between 2005 and 2024 about £1.187bn left the club in interest, debt repayments, dividends and fees. Ratcliffe now owns 28.94% and controls football operations, but the Glazers remain the majority: six of the twelve directors are family members and must approve decisions such as this one (BBC Sport).

5. Decisions that get reversed. INEOS decided to sack Ten Hag in the summer of 2024, changed its mind after the FA Cup win, and sacked him anyway in October. Amorim was chosen next and lasted about 14 months (BBC Sport). These are signs of a project that still lacks a stable direction.

What complicates the idea

1. Managers matter too. Under the same structure, Amorim's side finished 15th in 2024-25, while Carrick, as interim, won 12 of 17 matches and took the team to 3rd in 2025-26. That turnaround did not come from a new organisation ch

2. It has not all been failure. Mourinho finished second and won the Europa League; Ten Hag won two cups. United have competed, just not for the league title.

3. A good structure guarantees nothing. Liverpool are the classic example of a well-run club: their sporting director, Michael Edwards, signed Salah, Van Dijk and Alisson, and the club won the 2019 Champions League and the 2020 league title (BBC Sport). They won the league again in 2025, yet finished 5th in 2025-26.

4. Patience is also a decision. Arsenal, the 2025-26 champions, kept Mikel Arteta from late 2019. The BBC describes it as a six-year project, and ten of their fifteen most-used players in the title season arrived under the previous sporting director, Edu. Even when Edu left in 2024, the plan continued. That says something about structure, but also about owners willing to wait.

What the evidence allows us to conclude

The evidence supports much of the idea. United have spent like few others, changed managers and executives many times, and have not kept a consistent recruitment plan. The ownership model, with debt and with power split between the Glazers and Ratcliffe, adds another layer to every decision. But the data also shows that a good manager can transform a season, and that the clubs that rebuilt well combined structure with patience.

For supporters, the useful question is not only "who will be the next manager?". It is also: who decides, with what plan, and for how long will that plan be respected? If Pochettino arrives, that will be the real test.

We will update the "What is happening now" section when the club makes an official announcement.

Sources

  1. Manchester United (official statement), “Mauricio Pochettino agrees to become United head coach”, 13 November 2026: manutd.com
  2. Manchester United, “Club statement on Michael Carrick”, 12 November 2026: manutd.com
  3. Sky Sports, "Mauricio Pochettino: Man Utd strike agreement with Michael Carrick's potential successor", 11 November 2026: skysports.com
  4. BBC Sport, "Mauricio Pochettino ready to accept Man Utd offer to replace Michael Carrick", 11 November 2026: bbc.com
  5. The Guardian, "Manchester United close on Mauricio Pochettino deal before settling Carrick's fate", 11 November 2026: theguardian.com
  6. AP / The Washington Post, "Man United does 'due diligence' on Pochettino", 11 November 2026: washingtonpost.com
  7. BBC Sport, "The Monaco summit that will decide the future of Carrick and Man Utd", 10 November 2026: bbc.co.uk
  8. BBC Sport, "Michael Carrick taking Tuesday training", 10 November 2026: bbc.com
  9. The Guardian, "Mauricio Pochettino interested in leaving USMNT job for Manchester United", 10 November 2026: theguardian.com
  10. BBC Sport, Premier League table (updated 9 November 2026): bbc.co.uk
  11. Sky Sports, "Man Utd have highest transfer net spend since 2022...", 11 September 2026: skysports.com
  12. Transfermarkt, "'Dumb money' - Why Man Utd transfer complaints are foolish after wasting billions", summer 2026: transfermarkt.co.uk
  13. Manchester United, Michael Carrick, Head Coach (contract confirmed 22 May 2026): manutd.com
  14. BBC Sport, "Boats, fire and a TikTok song - inside Arsenal's title win", 19 May 2026: bbc.com
  15. Premier League, "Everything that's been decided in 2025/26 Premier League", 24 May 2026: premierleague.com
  16. Premier League, "Ten things we learned from the 2024/25 Premier League season", 30 May 2025: premierleague.com
  17. BBC Verify / BBC Sport, "How the Glazer family cost Manchester United £1.2bn", 6 June 2025: bbc.co.uk
  18. BBC Sport, "Dan Ashworth leaves Manchester United sporting director role after just five months", 8 December 2024: bbc.co.uk
  19. Reuters, "List of Manchester United managers since Alex Ferguson retired", 1 November 2024: reuters.com
  20. BBC Sport, "Liverpool owners FSG appoint Michael Edwards as their chief executive of football", 12 March 2024: bbc.com
  21. BBC Sport, "Man Utd chief executive Richard Arnold to leave club", 15 November 2023: bbc.co.uk
  22. BBC Sport, "Richard Arnold to replace Ed Woodward as chief executive on 1 February", 6 January 2022: bbc.com
  23. BBC Sport, "Darren Fletcher appointed technical director" (John Murtough as football director), 10 March 2021: bbc.com
  24. BBC Sport, "Man Utd director of football: Is Paul Mitchell the ideal candidate and how will role work?", December 2018: bbc.com
  25. Manchester United, Trophy Room (FA Cup, League Cup and Europa League): manutd.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top